Sunday, October 28, 2012

Apple, SAP & Hewlett-Packard: Not Just Numbers, Company's Vision, Strategy and Goals Also Matter For Investors (Part I)

In this two-part blog, I will share my view points on why investors price certain stocks at higher or lower multiples against market defying conventional wisdom which suggests that higher (lower) growth stocks should fetch higher (lower) multiples than that of the market.  

In part I of this two-part blog, I offer empirical evidence suggesting that few consistently outperforming technology companies get valuation treatments that defy conventional wisdom.  Faster growing companies get lower multiples while slow and steadily growing companies get higher multiples.  

In part II of this blog, I will conclude by suggesting that a clearly articulated long term strategy along with measurable corporate goals play an equally important role together with the company’s financial track record and market beating performance in winning investors' heart (and getting higher multiples.)  

To help me illustrate my view points, I assembled a small group of traditional tech companies including Apple (Ticker: AAPL), Oracle (Ticker: ORCL), Hewlett-Packard (Ticker: HPQ), Microsoft (Ticker: MSFT), IBM (Ticker: IBM), SAP (Ticker: SAP), and Google (Ticker: GOOG).  I selected S&P 500 (SP500) as the market.  

As of Oct 19, SP500’s Trailing P/E and estimates for Forward P/E were 17 and 13.8 respectively (see the side table.)  AAPL’s 52-weeks return of 50.5% has markedly outpaced the same period return of 9.95% for SP500.  In addition, AAPL’s earnings growth has substantively outpaced that of SP 500 for five straight years (see the side chart). So I started to wonder why AAPL’s Trailing and Forward PE multiples of 14.3 and 11.4 trail that of S&P 500 (see the table below).  Is there a crisis looming for AAPL that could be bigger in magnitude and impact than those faced by the financial markets including the never-ending debt crisis in Europe, a worsening slowdown in China and an already unraveling fiscal cliff in the US.  So, why are investors not pricing AAPL using the multiples of SP500 at the minimum?

Consider SAP:  In a peer group comprising of  four enterprise software tech companies - SAP, IBM, ORCL and MSFT, SAP has the highest Trailing P/E and the highest Price/Sales ratio (see the table below).  SAP’s Forward P/E of 19.7 is 9 points higher than that of ORCL, 11 points higher than that of MSFT and 8 points higher than that of IBM.  In addition, SAP’s Forward and Trailing P/E multiples are also higher than that of SP500!  So, why investors are willing to price SAP stock at higher multiples than the others in its peer group including the SP500.  Interestingly, SAP’s multiples are also higher than that of AAPL.  


Finally, let’s drop HPQ into the mix:  HPQ’s TTM revenue was $61.9 per share (see the table above).  Its stock is trading at a meager P/S multiple of .2x and has a Forward P/E multiple of just 4.  This is not hard to explain as there is no love left between HPQ and its investors who have suffered heavy losses in HPQ which has dropped almost 50% just this year alone.  In addition, at such lower multiples, investors are definitely pricing in a catastrophic scenario.

Source: Morning Star and Yahoo Finance
For all these companies, I assembled last 5 years income statements and I reviewed their revenue growth rates (see the side table).  Nothing jumped out that could have suggested why AAPL should have lower multiples than the SP500, GOOG or  SAP.  Clearly, there is something else at play which traditional valuation approach is not explaining.


Investors’ actions in HPQ, AAPL, SAP and its peers can be justified by applying following three simple rules of investment: 
  1. invest in companies you know, understand and believe;
  2.  invest in companies which are going to persist, pursue positive NPV projects and successfully sail with the wind (market trends); &
  3. invest in companies for mid-long term.
 Investors closely scrutinize, more than one would desire, the company management’s effectiveness in articulating its future and corporate goals and the trustworthiness.  This is where the “believe” part in the first rule comes in.  In part II of this blog, I will apply this set of principles to few companies in this group and discuss the outcome.

This blog has benefited from the discussions with my friends and colleagues Jens DoerpmundRyan Leask and Rajani Aswani on this topic.

Disclaimer:  All numbers are approximate and the underlying analysis is preliminary.  This blog is not intended for offering any investment advice.  SAP is my employer but all the views and opinions expressed here are solely mine.

93 comments:

  1. sap upgrade automation
    This post is a very interesting one! I recommended to all my colleagues to read it! I really like reading your blog ! I can always find here the things I am looking for!

    ReplyDelete
  2. very nice article.Thanks for Sharing the post...!
    Java Online Training

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is very interesting to learn from to easy understood. Thank you for giving information. Please let us know and more information get post to link.

    interview question and answer

    ReplyDelete
  4. we have a technique of deleting the capability which you have put immediately from our storage. Thus, there's no risk of data getting violated. You should arrive at us with regards to a QuickBooks Customer Support Number of software issues.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The QuickBooks Customer Support Number will not fix completely until you comprehend the main cause associated with problem. As company file plays an extremely crucial role in account management, so that it becomes only a little tough to spot.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Usually the one who has got deficiencies in knowledge battle to check out along side options. QuickBooks Enterprise Support Number can either perform payment processing in desktop or cloud, both ways are a little different but provide you with the same results.

    ReplyDelete
  7. With regards to features and functionality, QuickBooks always tops the list of perfect accounting software. From accuracy to speed, this software gives the perfection to your accounting process. QuickBooks uses web soul to exhibit all internet based pages. While focusing on this software, you may face an error while wanting to have a look at webpages from QuickBooks program. A mistake message pops through to your screen specifying the error. Don’t panic, because we are only at QuickBooks Support Phone Number to help you recognize the error and its resolution. We now have a team of dedicate and technically skilled professionals to present you the absolute most reliable technical assistance in QuickBooks.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The Quickbooks Payroll Support Phone Number team at site name is held responsible for removing the errors that pop up in this desirable software. We care for not letting any issue can be purchased in in the middle of your work and trouble you in undergoing your tasks. Many of us resolves most of the QuickBooks Payroll issue this type of a fashion that you'll yourself believe that your issue is resolved without you wasting the time into it. We take toll on every issue through the use of our highly trained customer care.

    ReplyDelete
  9. If you’re looking for small-business accounting solutions, initial thing experts and happy costumers will recommend you is QuickBooks Support Phone Number by Intuit Inc. Intuit’s products for construction contractors through the Quickbooks Pro, Simple Start Plus Pack, Quickbooks Premier Contractor, and Quickbooks Enterprise .

    ReplyDelete
  10. You can very quickly all from the QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number to learn more details. Let’s see many of your choices that are included with QuickBooks that has made the QuickBooks payroll service exremely popular.

    ReplyDelete
  11. We now have experienced individuals to offer the figure. We are going to also provide you with the figure of your respective budget which you can be in the long run from now. This will be only possible with QuickBooks Support Phone Number.

    ReplyDelete
  12. QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number! If you’re not able to customize employee payroll in Quickbooks which makes the list optimally, in QB and QB desktop, then read the description ahead. Here, you will get the determination of numerous kind of information what you’ve readily available for assisting the setup process with comfort.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Welcome aboard, to your support site par excellence where all your worries related to the functioning of QuickBooks Enterprise will be addressed by our world-class team of QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number once you go through the blink of a wrist watch. If you're experiencing any hiccups

    ReplyDelete
  14. If for those who run into any QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number or problems or would really like any facilitate, you’ll dial the direct line variety to succeed in the QuickBooks specialists.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Every time you dial Quickbooks Support Phone Number, your queries get instantly solved. Moreover, you may get in contact with our professional technicians via our email and chat support choices for prompt resolution of most related issues.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Our QuickBooks 24 Hour Customer Service channel- We comprehend the complexity and need with this accounting software in day to day life. You can’t wait for pretty much time and energy to get a fix of each and every single QB error. Therefore we have designed a especially dedicated team of certified professionals at QuickBooks Technical Support contact number that are capable of understanding your issues and errors in minimum time as well as in the most convenient way. Dial our toll-free and avail the QuickBooks Tech Support Number offered at the most pocket friendly price.

    ReplyDelete
  17. On September 22, 2014, Intuit publicized the release of QuickBooks 2015 with types that users have been completely demanding through the last versions. Amended income tracker, pinned notes, better registration process and understandings on homepage are among the list of general alterations for most versions of QuickBooks 2015. It will also help for QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number to acquire technical help & support for QuickBooks.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Just dial our QuickBooks Payroll Support Number to inquire about for Quickbooks Payroll customer care to resolve payroll issues. We make use of startups to small-scale, medium-sized to multinational companies.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This might be basically the right time so you can get the QuickBooks Support Phone Number In United States. We have trained staff to soft your issue. Sometimes errors could also happen as a consequence of some small mistakes.Our professionals are terribly dedicated and might solve your entire issues without the fuss.

    ReplyDelete
  20. basic, premium, and pro. Your choice of a package will depend on the sheer number of software users, and a period period you intend to receive our services. The packages include unlimited QuickBooks Desktop Support Phone Number online customer service and 24/7 tech support team.

    ReplyDelete
  21. QuickBooks Payroll Support Number will be possible to very easily keep track of 50 employees at a time and you also can monitor the sheer number of working hours of each and every employee. It will help you in calculating the complete soon add up to be paid to a worker depending until the number of hours he/she has contributed of their work.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Each time you dial QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number, your queries get instantly solved. Moreover, you may get in contact with our professional technicians via our email and chat support choices for prompt resolution of most related issues.

    ReplyDelete
  23. QuickBook Support Phone Number offers an extensive financial solution, where it keeps all your valuable business accounting requirements in a single place. From estimates to bank transfers, invoicing to tracking your expenses and staying in addition to bookkeeping when it comes to tax time, it really is prepared for all of it at one go.

    ReplyDelete
  24. To have more enhanced results and optimized benefits, you are able to take the help of experts making a call at QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support Number. Well! If you’re not in a position to customize employee payroll in Quickbooks while making the list optimally, in QB and QB desktop, then browse the description ahead. Here, you receive the determination of numerous kind of information what you’ve close by for assisting the setup process with comfort.

    ReplyDelete
  25. QuickBooks Technical Support it is easy to seek optimal solutions if any error hinders your work. With QuickBooks Pro you can easily easily effortlessly create invoices and keep close track of every little thing like exacltly what the shoppers

    ReplyDelete
  26. QuickBooks 2019 could be the better account management product till now. The recent improvement that's been manufactured in this system regarding current user requirements as well as the methods to overcome the limitation of previous QuickBooks versions. We've been here to improve your understanding in regards to the payroll updates happens in QuickBooks Enterprise, desktop, pro, premier 2019 versions. Solve your queries associated with QuickBooks Online Payroll whether Enhanced or Full Service. Fix all the issues for QuickBooks Desktop Payroll Basic, Standard, & Payroll Assisted. Check out the above mentioned number to make contact with our ProAdvisor to possess support for QuickBooks Payroll Tech Support Phone Number, Intuit Online & Full Service Payroll.

    ReplyDelete
  27. “Just dial our QuickBooks Payroll Support number to inquire of about for Quickbooks Payroll customer care to get rid of payroll issues. We take advantage of startups to small-scale, medium-sized to multinational companies.”

    ReplyDelete
  28. Thus, the user can solve the HP Printer Phone Support Number problem in HP Printer where in fact the device is within error state by simply following the instructions prompt installing the latest print head.

    ReplyDelete
  29. If you are merely facing any type of errors or issues every day with your QuickBooks Support accounting software then don’t be worried about it. Primeaxle always provides you with the very best and most amazing team to simply resolve or fix your errors or issues whenever you want.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Our experts team at QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number is going to make you realize its advanced functions and assists anyone to lift up your business growth.

    ReplyDelete
  31. QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number Premier is a favorite product from QuickBooks recognized for letting the company people easily monitor their business-related expenses; track inventory at their convenience, track the status of an invoice and optimize the data files without deleting the info.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Encountering a slip-up or Technical break down of your QuickBooks or its functions can be associate degree obstacle and put your work on a halt. this can be not solely frustrating however additionally a heavy concern as all of your crucial information is saved on the code information. For the actual reason, dig recommends that you simply solely dial the authentic Intuit QuickBooks Support sign anytime you would like any facilitate along with your QuickBooks. Our QuickBooks specialists can assist you remotely over a network.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Whether or not you're getting performance errors or maybe you may be facing almost any trouble to upgrade your software to its latest version, it is possible to quickly get advice about Intuit QuickBooks Support .

    ReplyDelete
  34. At QuickBooks Support Phone Number, you will discover solution every single issue that bothers your projects and creates hindrance in running your company smoothly.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Search towards the chart of accounts really is easy to manage with added search bar right when you look at the chart of accounts. For better information, you might call at QuickBooks Enterprise Support Phone Number.You can find account, sub-account & search predicated on account name & number.

    ReplyDelete
  36. QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number offers a thorough financial solution, where it keeps all your valuable business accounting requirements in one place. From estimates to bank transfers, invoicing to tracking your expenses and staying along with bookkeeping when it comes to tax time, it really is prepared for all of it at one go.

    ReplyDelete
  37. We're going to allow you to streamline and simplify the accounting, reporting and tracking so that managing your company’s finances could be much easier. Also, we guarantee to keep up anonymity and high level of security while handling issues linked to QB software use. Our QuickBooks Technical Support Phone Number can be obtained for you at any time. Get in touch with us by utilizing an unknown number or email indicated regarding the Quickbooks Support site. We will be pleased to work with you with any question about QuickBooks you may have.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Most support teams provide you with tech teams online who have studied the Quickbooks enterprise software. With QuickBooks Enterprise Tech Support Number, we go the extra mile. We get you in touch with experts who have not only used the software for a prolonged period of time. But, have also gained extensive knowledge about all the practical uses and figured out the nuances. Nuances that an average user might not possess the intel about.

    ReplyDelete
  39. In May 2002 Intuit thrown QuickBooks Enterprise Solutions for medium-sized businesses. QuickBooks Enterprise Support Number here to create tech support team to users. In September 2005, QuickBooks acquired 74% share associated with market in america. A June 19, 2008 Intuit Press Announcement said that during the time of March 2008, QuickBooks’ share of retail units within the industry accounting group touched 94.2 percent, according to NPD Group.

    ReplyDelete
  40. If you are having concerns, you are getting support by sending your queries through e-mail towards the QuickBooks Payroll Support Number experts.

    ReplyDelete
  41. You can easily reach our QuickBooks Payroll Support at any time in most throughout the USA. And you can also ask us for anything pertaining to QuickBooks whatever your enquiry is like, understand QuickBooks features, Error fixing, creating an invoice or send an invoice, financial report, manage taxes, etc.

    ReplyDelete
  42. QuickBooks customer support team is best for offering their services delivered on time whether it's day or night. The team of experts are highly experienced and certified in solving any technical and nontechnical issues. And also you also have the best technical support through the QuickBooks Support contact number team so that you work properly on your own accounts and improve your business. The QuickBooks support executives will likely to be available 24/7 just for their users. So, get quick help by contacting the QuickBooks Tech Support Phone Number.

    ReplyDelete
  43. QuickBooks is a great accounting software but at times while working on this great platform you may face some nasty error. One such error is QuickBooks Error 6000 301. Dial our 1-855-236-7529 and get immediate help from our proficient experts to resolve QuickBooks Error 6000 301.
    Read more: https://tinyurl.com/y3cf5jc3

    ReplyDelete
  44. Though it is the fact that it is only most efficient software for accounting packages you may find, in some instances some specific problems for help. Fortunately, you may also cause them to to disappear in just few moments, just through a call on the customer care or perhaps the toll-free QuickBooks Support Phone Number.

    ReplyDelete
  45. QuickBooks Support Phone Number Services provide methods to your entire QuickBooks problem and in addition assists in identifying the errors with QuickBooks data files and diagnose them thoroughly before resolving these issues.

    ReplyDelete
  46. QuickBooks Tecnical Support Number could be contacted to master the techniques to produce a computerized backup to save lots of your entire employee-related data from getting bugged or lost at any circumstances.

    ReplyDelete
  47. QuickBooks Payroll is one of the most demanding versions of QuickBooks that can help you to track your income and expenses. But unlike any other software, it too has some flaws. Dial our QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1(800)674-9538 and get best answers for your QB payroll errors. For More Visit: https://issuu.com/payroll.qbs/docs/quickbooks_support_phone_number__8o

    ReplyDelete
  48. QuickBooks, an astounding accounting software is available both as online as well as desktop version. We are available at our QuickBooks Support Phone Number USA +1 800-674-9538 to eliminate each and every error that pops up. For More Visit: https://www.payrollsupportphonenumber.com/quickbooks-support-phone-number-usa/

    ReplyDelete
  49. I just loved your blog and shared it faster than I actually read it. Through all this, I mean to convey that your post was amazing and well-crafted. One needs such posts to know in details. You can get analysis and verification of QuickBooks working at QuickBooks Enterprise Support 1 (888) 238-7409. Visit us:- https://www.enetquickbookenterprise.com

    ReplyDelete
  50. If you face difficulty in using the software, call us on QuickBooks payroll support phone number 1*833*441*8848. QuickBooks payroll is the #1 payday accounts managing software, through which users can pay their employees in a few clicks.

    ReplyDelete
  51. Thank you for sharing such an amazing post my friend, your post is absolutely so inspiring every time. Keep sharing frequently! QuickBooks is an eminent accounting software that simplifies all your accounting and financial transactions, without any human error. Thus, if you want to know more about this accounting software, you can contact QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number +1-800-272-7634, and avail the perfect response from the experts here.

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hi! Great work. I have read many blogs earlier but haven’t read such a beautiful post before. Thanks for sharing such a remarkable work. If you are looking for powerful accounting software, then go for QuickBooks. It is leading accounting software that is used by small-sized businesses. To get support for errors, reach us via QuickBooks Customer Care+1-800-272-7634.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hey! Superb blog. It is the best post that you have written so far. Do you know QuickBooks is reliable accounting software that helps freelancers and growing businesses manage their accounting and payroll needs? You can easily install the software. You can even get instant help at QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number +1-800-272-7634.

    ReplyDelete
  54. Hey! Outstanding post. I found your blog interesting to read. Thanks for sharing such a nice blog. I hope you will post some more blogs on the same topic. If you are searching for accounting software which has lots of features for managing business accounts, then go for QuickBooks Desktop software. QuickBooks Desktop is one of the most prevalent accounting software that is used by small and medium-sized businesses. The software consists of a great bunch of features that has fascinated millions of customers. If you ever encounter an error in your software, dial QuickBooks Desktop Support Phone Number 1-844-200-2627 and get effective solutions for your queries. Visit us:https://www.enetservepartners.com/quickbooks-desktop-support/

    ReplyDelete
  55. Thank you mate, for sharing such a wonderful post! QuickBooks Point of Sale is one of the most power-packed versions of QuickBooks that assist the users to streamline their business at a rapid pace. This amazing software easily manages and completes all the accounting and financial tasks of the business perfectly. If you want to educate yourself more about this software you can contact our specialists at QuickBooks Customer Support Phone Number +1-833-674-9538 24X7 hours.

    ReplyDelete
  56. This is an amazing post, thank you mate for sharing such an informative and crispy post. QuickBooks is an accounting application that provides the users to run and operate their businesses’ accounting tasks smoothly. However, QuickBooks may come across numerous bugs while using this software, thus to get it fixed timely, contact our experts at QuickBooks Customer Care +1-833-674-9538 and get valid information anytime.

    ReplyDelete
  57. Hey! Outstanding Post. It is one of the best things that I have read on the internet today. After reading your informative articles, I immediately subscribed to your blogging channel. I hope you will post some more valuable posts. In case you want a reliable accounting software for your business, then go for QuickBooks. To know how to get started with the software, contact experts via QuickBooks Helpline Number 1-833-401-0204.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Now enter the “Registered name, registered current email address” and submit it. Required corresponding response with all the suitable fixing may be made available within ten trading days. If you want to Resolve QuickBooks Error 9999 then you may contact our ProAdvisors.

    ReplyDelete
  59. QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-844-232-O2O2. Using this vast and efficient software sometimes can prove to be hectic and confusing. This accounting software is vulnerable to several technical bugs and errors. To get rid of such errors or technical issues you can simply call our experts who are available round-the-clock at your service and provides prolific solution with limited average hold calls.
    visit us:-https://qbsupportphonenumber.site123.me/

    ReplyDelete
  60. QuickBooks users might face technical issues but they can resolve them shortly, with the help of brilliant executives. They can report all queries and problems to customer care executives. The squad would provide meaningful solutions to its users at QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-844-232-O2O2.visit us:-https://jamessmithsu.wixsite.com/quickbookssupport & read more:-https://tinyurl.com/y42ywocq

    ReplyDelete
  61. QuickBooks software faces the brunt of users frustration due to hidden technical glitches or bugs. Thus, to solve such annoying errors, dial QuickBooks Support Phone Number +1-844-232-O2O2 and get feasible solutions for QuickBooks queries.
    visit us:-https://buzzmytech.com/read-blog/1873

    ReplyDelete
  62. QuickBooks error 9999 appears during program installation. Also, an error occurs while QuickBooks is running, during windows start up or shut down or even during the installation of the Windows operating system. If you would like to learn how to Resolve Quickbooks Error 9999, you can continue reading this blog.

    ReplyDelete
  63. Our QuickBooks experts are always available to deliver round the clock assistance to users. Don’t hesitate to call on QuickBooks Support Phone Number ever, as by dialing +1(833)780-0086. you will get connected with QuickBooks experts. For More Visit: https://g.page/qb-support-number-hawaii

    ReplyDelete
  64. When Found QuickBooks Banking Error 103, don’t get worried about it. Immediately ring a call to us at 1-855-9O7-O4O6. Arrival of QuickBooks Banking error indicates that your sign-in credentials don't match with your Bank’s website.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Well explained!
    getting QuickBooks error and any issues ? get in touch with our QuickBooks expert for efficient solution.
    Dial QuickBooks Customer Service Phone Number +1-844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  66. Nice Blog!
    QuickBooks error code 6129 0 ? Get live support 24*7 from QuickBooks expert on tool-free Number.
    Click here to know how to fix QuickBooks error code 6129 0
    Dial for any tech support: 1-844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  67. Nice Blog
    QuickBooks Payroll is a widely used accounting software that is intended for the business of small as well as large sizes. From among other QuickBooks editions, this one is the best. Call QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number at 1-855-6OO-4O6O.

    ReplyDelete
  68. Our team of experts and Proadvisers are always providing comprehensive bookkeeping and financial solutions to boost business account for everyone. So that's why we highly suggest you dial our QuickBooks Proadvisor Support Phone Number 1-855-6OO-4O6O

    ReplyDelete
  69. Well Explained !
    Getting QBWC1005: QuickBooks Web Connector Failed to Run display? Don’t worry, make a call at 1-855-6OO-4O6O & get solutions instantly.

    ReplyDelete
  70. nice post!
    Worried about QuickBooks Support ? Get in touch with QuickBooks expert for instant solution.Our Professional live 24*7 for Quick solution.
    Dial QuickBooks Phone Number 1-844-908-0801
    QuickBooks Customer Service

    ReplyDelete
  71. nice post!
    Dial on QuickBooks payroll support Phone Number for free ,Get in touch with QuickBooks expert for instant solution.Our Professional live 24*7 for Quick solution.
    Dial QuickBooks Payroll Support Phone Number 1-844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  72. nice post!
    QuickBooks connection diagnostic tools ?Get in touch with QuickBooks expert for instant solution.
    Click Here to Know How to Fix QuickBooks error code 1402 1-844-908-0801

    ReplyDelete
  73. nice post!
    Worried About QuickBooks Support ?Get in touch with QuickBooks expert for instant solution.
    Dial QuickBooks Support Phone Number Pennsylvania +1-888-603-9404

    ReplyDelete